KMAC  Sleep PicksShopping from

Choosing a mattress by sleep position

Firmness is the one decision that matters most, and it depends on how you sleep, not on what felt nice in a showroom.

Side: softer to medium. Back: medium-firm. Front: firmer. Sharing: go by the heavier or sorer partner. Then buy from someone with a long home trial. More on timing and trials on the mattress page.

Our pick

A mattress with a long home trial

Emma (current range varies by country)

Why: A long home trial matters more than any review, including ours: only your own back can tell you, over weeks. Emma won a Good Housekeeping award in the UK in 2026 and has a strong on-site rating.

How to use it: Side sleepers: softer to medium. Back: medium-firm. Front: firmer. If two share, go by whoever is heavier or has the sorer back.

The honest downside: Emma's Trustpilot score is middling (around 3.5 in Ireland), mostly complaints about delivery and after-sales service rather than the mattress. Put the trial end date in your calendar the day it arrives.

See it at Emma (US) →

See it at Emma (Canada) →

See it at Emma (UK) →

See it at Emma (Ireland) →

See it at Emma (Australia) →

Emma doesn't list New Zealand as a delivery country. Check their site before ordering.

Emma also sells in much of Europe. Check emma-sleep.com for your country before ordering.

A mattress with a long home trial

Layla Memory Foam (US; flippable soft/firm)

Why: One side is softer and the other firmer, so if you guess wrong you flip it instead of returning it. It comes with a 120-night home trial, free shipping and returns, and a lifetime warranty, and it is made in the US. About $999 for a queen when we checked.

How to use it: Side sleepers usually start on the soft side; back and front sleepers on the firm side. Give it two to three weeks before you judge it. If two share, go by whoever is heavier or has the sorer back.

The honest downside: All-foam mattresses sleep warmer than hybrids with springs, and the copper in the foam is marketing more than proven cooling. The "sale ends in" clock keeps restarting, so don't rush, and read the trial terms before you order: the site mentions both a 30-night and a 120-night window.

See Layla (120-night trial) →